2008 United States presidential election in Montana
 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 County Results
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Elections in Montana |
|---|
 |
The 2008 United States presidential election in Montana took place on November 4, 2008, and was part of the 2008 United States presidential election. Voters chose three representatives, or electors to the Electoral College, who voted for president and vice president.
Montana was won by Republican nominee John McCain by 11,096 votes, a 2.26% margin of victory. Before the election, Montana was initially viewed as safe Republican, but was viewed as lean Republican or toss-up in the final weeks. Historically the state is a Republican stronghold, but polls during the 2008 election showed Democrat Barack Obama just narrowly trailing Republican John McCain within the margin of error. On election day, McCain narrowly carried Montana. It was the fourth-closest state in the nation, behind Missouri, North Carolina, and Indiana, Missouri being a former bellwether state, and the other three being traditionally Republican states.
Despite the fact that Bill Clinton carried the state in 1992, Barack Obama's 47.25% of the vote was (and as of 2020 remains) the highest percent of the vote received by any Democratic candidate for president since 1964. Bill Clinton's victory in 1992 and near miss in 1996 were attributed to Ross Perot's strong third party candidacy in 1992 and 1996, the only other elections since 1964 when Montana was decided by under 5%. Obama was able to flip seven of Montana's counties from Republican to Democratic compared to the 2004 election.
Primaries
[edit]- 2008 Montana Democratic presidential primary
- 2008 Montana Republican presidential caucuses and primary
Campaign
[edit]Predictions
[edit]There were 15 news organizations who made state-by-state predictions of the election. Here are their last predictions before election day:
| Source | Ranking |
|---|---|
| D.C. Political Report[1] | Likely R |
| Cook Political Report[2] | Toss-up |
| The Takeaway[3] | Lean R |
| Electoral-vote.com[4] | Lean R |
| Washington Post[5] | Lean R |
| Politico[6] | Lean R |
| RealClearPolitics[7] | Toss-up |
| FiveThirtyEight[5] | Toss-up |
| The New York Times[8] | Lean R |
| CNN[9] | Toss-up |
| NPR[5] | Lean R |
| MSNBC[5] | Toss-up |
| Fox News[10] | Likely R |
| Associated Press[11] | Likely R |
| Rasmussen Reports[12] | Toss-up |
Polling
[edit]Although Republican George W. Bush of Texas carried Montana by double digits in both 2000 and 2004, polls taken throughout July indicated a close race between Republican John McCain of Arizona and Democrat Barack Obama of Illinois. When Governor Sarah Palin of Alaska was announced as McCain's running mate in late August, however, McCain took a double-digit lead in the state that lasted until the middle of October, when polling once again showed the two candidates within striking distance of each other in the state. When the actual 2008 presidential election took place, McCain carried the state by about 2.38%.[13] The state's results were significantly closer than they were in the 2004 election when George W. Bush carried the state by a margin of 20 points.[14]
Fundraising
[edit]John McCain raised a total of $386,940 in the state. Barack Obama raised $1,089,874.[15]
Advertising and visits
[edit]Obama and his interest groups spent $1,732,467. McCain and his interest groups spent just $134,805.[16] The Democratic ticket visited the state three times and McCain did not visit the state.[17]
Analysis
[edit]Montana, a Republican-leaning state, has voted for the Republican presidential nominee in every election since 1968 except in 1992 when the state narrowly supported Democrat Bill Clinton to Republican George H. W. Bush.
Obama did very well among the Democratic base of Montana, which consists of three sections. Students in Missoula County, which is home to the University of Montana, helped him win a three-to-two margin there. In the southwest, Obama won more than 65% of the vote in Deer Lodge County and Silver Bow County—Democratic strongholds which have voted Republican only twice since 1912; Obama also became the first Democratic presidential nominee to win Gallatin County, home to Bozeman, since Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1944. Finally, Native Americans gave Obama strong support; in the eastern part of the state, Obama only won counties in which Native Americans composed at least 30% of the population.
McCain's base was in the eastern part of the state, which is less unionized and more rural. It is home to more ranchers and fewer miners than elsewhere. Only five counties voted Democratic in the east. In Western Montana, McCain generally won wherever Obama's Democratic base was lacking. His biggest margins came from the region bordering the GOP bastion of Idaho.
There was also a relatively high third-party vote, totaling 3.26%. The Montana Constitution Party ran libertarian-leaning Republican U.S. Representative Ron Paul of Texas on their line (against his wishes), winning 2.17% of the vote in Montana, which was the highest statewide percentage total for any third-party candidate in the 2008 presidential election. A significant number of write-in candidates also ran in the state, with some beating third-party candidates.
During the same election, incumbent Democratic Governor Brian Schweitzer was reelected to a second term in a landslide over Republican Roy Brown and Libertarian Stan Jones. Winning by more than a two-to-one margin, Schweitzer received 65.21% of the vote while Brown took in 32.77% and Jones got 2.03%. Also during the same election, incumbent Democratic Senator Max Baucus was handily reelected to a sixth term over perennial candidate Bob Kelleher running as a Republican, no third-party candidate was in the race. Due to Kelleher's policies, such as adopting a parliamentary system in the United States, adopting a single-payer healthcare system, and nationalizing American oil and gas industries, he received no support from Montana GOP, and Baucus defeated Kelleher by nearly a 3-to-1 margin, taking in 72.92% over Kelleher's 27.08% and winning every single county in the state. At the state level, however, Republicans picked up three seats in the Montana Senate and gained control of the chamber. Democrats picked up the office of Secretary of State.
As of the 2020 presidential election[update], this is the last election where Montana was seriously contested, as well as the last one in which Lake County, Cascade County, Rosebud County, and Lewis and Clark County voted for the Democratic candidate. This is the last time the Big Sky Country would be decided by a single-digit margin, and the last time a candidate won the state with less than half of the vote. Obama became the first ever Democrat to win the White House without carrying Mineral or Sheridan Counties.
Results
[edit]| 2008 United States presidential election in Montana[18] | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Party | Candidate | Running mate | Votes | Percentage | Electoral votes | |
| Republican | John McCain | Sarah Palin | 242,763 | 49.51% | 3 | |
| Democratic | Barack Obama | Joe Biden | 231,667 | 47.25% | 0 | |
| Constitution | Ron Paul (no campaign) | Michael Peroutka | 10,638 | 2.17% | 0 | |
| Independent | Ralph Nader | Matt Gonzalez | 3,686 | 0.75% | 0 | |
| Libertarian | Bob Barr | Wayne Allyn Root | 1,355 | 0.28% | 0 | |
| (write-in) | Write-in candidates | 193 | 0.04% | 0 | ||
| Totals | 490,302 | 100.00% | 3 | |||
| Voter turnout (Voting age population) | 67.4% | |||||
By county
[edit]| County | John McCain Republican |
Barack Obama Democratic |
Various candidates Other parties |
Margin | Total | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| # | % | # | % | # | % | # | % | ||
| Beaverhead | 3,008 | 63.15% | 1,617 | 33.95% | 138 | 2.90% | 1,391 | 29.20% | 4,763 |
| Big Horn | 1,628 | 31.19% | 3,516 | 67.37% | 75 | 1.44% | -1,888 | -36.18% | 5,219 |
| Blaine | 1,139 | 38.93% | 1,702 | 58.17% | 85 | 2.90% | -563 | -19.24% | 2,926 |
| Broadwater | 1,875 | 66.80% | 857 | 30.53% | 75 | 2.67% | 1,018 | 36.27% | 2,807 |
| Carbon | 3,108 | 54.05% | 2,443 | 42.49% | 199 | 3.46% | 665 | 11.56% | 5,750 |
| Carter | 573 | 79.36% | 111 | 15.37% | 38 | 5.27% | 462 | 63.99% | 722 |
| Cascade | 16,857 | 47.62% | 17,664 | 49.90% | 875 | 2.48% | -807 | -2.28% | 35,396 |
| Chouteau | 1,634 | 57.11% | 1,122 | 39.22% | 105 | 3.67% | 512 | 17.89% | 2,861 |
| Custer | 3,047 | 55.89% | 2,267 | 41.58% | 138 | 2.53% | 780 | 14.31% | 5,452 |
| Daniels | 694 | 64.68% | 343 | 31.97% | 36 | 3.35% | 351 | 32.71% | 1,073 |
| Dawson | 2,639 | 59.38% | 1,593 | 35.85% | 212 | 4.77% | 1,046 | 23.53% | 4,444 |
| Deer Lodge | 1,502 | 29.60% | 3,402 | 67.05% | 170 | 3.35% | -1,900 | -37.45% | 5,074 |
| Fallon | 1,064 | 74.25% | 318 | 22.19% | 51 | 3.56% | 746 | 52.06% | 1,433 |
| Fergus | 4,108 | 65.92% | 1,933 | 31.02% | 191 | 3.06% | 2,175 | 34.90% | 6,232 |
| Flathead | 25,559 | 58.43% | 16,138 | 36.89% | 2,047 | 4.68% | 9,421 | 21.54% | 43,744 |
| Gallatin | 22,578 | 46.77% | 24,205 | 50.14% | 1,489 | 3.09% | -1,627 | -3.37% | 48,272 |
| Garfield | 598 | 82.26% | 110 | 15.13% | 19 | 2.61% | 488 | 67.13% | 727 |
| Glacier | 1,451 | 29.19% | 3,423 | 68.86% | 97 | 1.95% | -1,972 | -39.67% | 4,971 |
| Golden Valley | 343 | 69.72% | 124 | 25.20% | 25 | 5.08% | 219 | 44.52% | 492 |
| Granite | 1,013 | 58.96% | 601 | 34.98% | 104 | 6.06% | 412 | 23.98% | 1,718 |
| Hill | 2,787 | 42.07% | 3,596 | 54.28% | 242 | 3.65% | -809 | -12.21% | 6,625 |
| Jefferson | 3,538 | 55.80% | 2,582 | 40.72% | 221 | 3.48% | 956 | 15.08% | 6,341 |
| Judith Basin | 801 | 64.81% | 397 | 32.12% | 38 | 3.07% | 404 | 32.69% | 1,236 |
| Lake | 6,498 | 46.56% | 6,766 | 48.48% | 692 | 4.96% | -268 | -1.92% | 13,956 |
| Lewis and Clark | 14,966 | 45.31% | 17,114 | 51.82% | 949 | 2.87% | -2,148 | -6.51% | 33,029 |
| Liberty | 594 | 59.34% | 367 | 36.66% | 40 | 4.00% | 227 | 22.68% | 1,001 |
| Lincoln | 5,704 | 61.82% | 3,025 | 32.78% | 498 | 5.40% | 2,679 | 29.04% | 9,227 |
| Madison | 2,822 | 61.78% | 1,607 | 35.18% | 139 | 3.04% | 1,215 | 26.60% | 4,568 |
| McCone | 726 | 66.54% | 321 | 29.42% | 44 | 4.04% | 405 | 37.12% | 1,091 |
| Meagher | 624 | 64.60% | 298 | 30.85% | 44 | 4.55% | 326 | 33.75% | 966 |
| Mineral | 1,053 | 52.73% | 845 | 42.31% | 99 | 4.96% | 208 | 10.42% | 1,997 |
| Missoula | 20,743 | 34.99% | 36,531 | 61.63% | 2,003 | 3.38% | -15,788 | -26.64% | 59,277 |
| Musselshell | 1,581 | 68.56% | 636 | 27.58% | 89 | 3.86% | 945 | 40.98% | 2,306 |
| Park | 4,376 | 49.18% | 4,173 | 46.90% | 349 | 3.92% | 203 | 2.28% | 8,898 |
| Petroleum | 227 | 75.67% | 68 | 22.67% | 5 | 1.66% | 159 | 53.00% | 300 |
| Phillips | 1,423 | 67.03% | 638 | 30.05% | 62 | 2.92% | 785 | 36.98% | 2,123 |
| Pondera | 1,588 | 55.04% | 1,223 | 42.39% | 74 | 2.57% | 365 | 12.65% | 2,885 |
| Powder River | 802 | 77.26% | 208 | 20.04% | 28 | 2.70% | 594 | 57.22% | 1,038 |
| Powell | 1,683 | 59.81% | 1,021 | 36.28% | 110 | 3.91% | 662 | 23.53% | 2,814 |
| Prairie | 503 | 68.44% | 211 | 28.71% | 21 | 2.85% | 292 | 39.73% | 735 |
| Ravalli | 13,002 | 58.83% | 8,400 | 38.01% | 699 | 3.16% | 4,602 | 20.82% | 22,101 |
| Richland | 3,184 | 70.50% | 1,203 | 26.64% | 129 | 2.86% | 1,981 | 43.86% | 4,516 |
| Roosevelt | 1,473 | 35.47% | 2,564 | 61.74% | 116 | 2.79% | -1,091 | -26.27% | 4,153 |
| Rosebud | 1,768 | 46.40% | 1,919 | 50.37% | 123 | 3.23% | -151 | -3.97% | 3,810 |
| Sanders | 3,563 | 60.72% | 1,970 | 33.57% | 335 | 5.71% | 1,593 | 27.15% | 5,868 |
| Sheridan | 987 | 49.20% | 953 | 47.51% | 66 | 3.29% | 34 | 1.69% | 2,006 |
| Silver Bow | 4,818 | 28.27% | 11,676 | 68.51% | 548 | 3.22% | -6,858 | -40.24% | 17,042 |
| Stillwater | 2,991 | 64.09% | 1,512 | 32.40% | 164 | 3.51% | 1,479 | 31.69% | 4,667 |
| Sweet Grass | 1,494 | 71.72% | 541 | 25.97% | 48 | 2.31% | 953 | 45.75% | 2,083 |
| Teton | 1,874 | 57.27% | 1,294 | 39.55% | 104 | 3.18% | 580 | 17.72% | 3,272 |
| Toole | 1,317 | 62.09% | 737 | 34.75% | 67 | 3.16% | 580 | 27.34% | 2,121 |
| Treasure | 314 | 64.61% | 156 | 32.10% | 16 | 3.29% | 158 | 32.51% | 486 |
| Valley | 2,121 | 54.23% | 1,645 | 42.06% | 145 | 3.71% | 476 | 12.17% | 3,911 |
| Wheatland | 657 | 66.84% | 289 | 29.40% | 37 | 3.76% | 368 | 37.44% | 983 |
| Wibaux | 379 | 67.32% | 146 | 25.93% | 38 | 6.75% | 233 | 41.39% | 563 |
| Yellowstone | 36,483 | 51.62% | 32,038 | 45.33% | 2,158 | 3.05% | 4,445 | 6.29% | 70,679 |
| Totals | 243,882 | 49.49% | 232,159 | 47.11% | 16,709 | 3.39% | 11,723 | 2.38% | 492,750 |
| Democratic Hold Gain from Republican | Republican Hold |
Counties that flipped from Republican to Democratic
[edit]- Blaine (largest city: Chinook)
- Cascade (largest city: Great Falls)
- Gallatin (largest city: Bozeman)
- Hill (largest city: Havre)
- Lake (largest city: Polson)
- Lewis and Clark (largest city: Helena)
- Rosebud (largest city: Colstrip)
By congressional district
[edit]Due to the state's low population, only one congressional district is allocated, the At-Large District. This district covers the entire state, and thus is equivalent to the statewide election results.
| District | McCain | Obama | Representative |
|---|---|---|---|
| At-large | 49.5% | 47.1% | Denny Rehberg |
Electors
[edit]Technically the voters of Montana cast their ballots for electors: representatives to the Electoral College. Montana is allocated 3 electors because it has 1 congressional district and 2 senators. All candidates who appear on the ballot or qualify to receive write-in votes must submit a list of 3 electors, who pledge to vote for their candidate and his or her running mate. Whoever wins the majority of votes in the state is awarded all 3 electoral votes. Their chosen electors then vote for president and vice president. Although electors are pledged to their candidate and running mate, they are not obligated to vote for them.[19] An elector who votes for someone other than his or her candidate is known as a faithless elector.
The electors of each state and the District of Columbia met on December 15, 2008, to cast their votes for president and vice president. The Electoral College itself never meets as one body. Instead the electors from each state and the District of Columbia met in their respective capitols.
The following were the members of the Electoral College from the state. All 3 were pledged to John McCain and Sarah Palin:[20]
- Thelma Baker
- John Brenden
- Errol Galt
See also
[edit]References
[edit]- ^ "D.C.'s Political Report: The complete source for campaign summaries". January 1, 2009. Archived from the original on January 1, 2009. Retrieved August 23, 2021.
- ^ "Presidential". May 5, 2015. Archived from the original on May 5, 2015. Retrieved August 23, 2021.
- ^ "Vote 2008 - The Takeaway - Track the Electoral College vote predictions". April 22, 2009. Archived from the original on April 22, 2009. Retrieved August 23, 2021.
- ^ "Electoral-vote.com: President, Senate, House Updated Daily". electoral-vote.com. Retrieved August 23, 2021.
- ^ a b c d Based on Takeaway
- ^ "POLITICO's 2008 Swing State Map - POLITICO.com". www.politico.com. Retrieved September 22, 2016.
- ^ "RealClearPolitics - Electoral Map". Archived from the original on June 5, 2008.
- ^ Nagourney, Adam; Zeleny, Jeff; Carter, Shan (November 4, 2008). "The Electoral Map: Key States". The New York Times. Retrieved May 26, 2010.
- ^ "October – 2008 – CNN Political Ticker - CNN.com Blogs". CNN. October 31, 2008. Archived from the original on June 19, 2010. Retrieved May 26, 2010.
- ^ "Winning The Electoral College". Fox News. April 27, 2010.
- ^ "roadto270". hosted.ap.org. Retrieved September 22, 2016.
- ^ "Election 2008: Electoral College Update - Rasmussen Reports". www.rasmussenreports.com. Retrieved September 22, 2016.
- ^ "RealClearPolitics - Election 2008 - Montana". Retrieved November 26, 2008.
- ^ "Electoral-vote.com". Retrieved November 26, 2008.
- ^ "Presidential Campaign Finance". Archived from the original on March 24, 2009. Retrieved August 19, 2009.
- ^ "Map: Campaign Ad Spending - Election Center 2008 from CNN.com". CNN. Retrieved May 26, 2010.
- ^ "Map: Campaign Candidate Visits - Election Center 2008 from CNN.com". CNN. Retrieved May 26, 2010.
- ^ "FEC Election Results 2008" (PDF).
- ^ "Electoral College". California Secretary of State. Archived from the original on October 30, 2008. Retrieved November 1, 2008.
- ^ "Archived copy" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on November 7, 2008. Retrieved November 11, 2008.
{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
