User:Balloonman/CSD Survey/2.3
| Quicklinks |
|---|
| Other Excellent articles on CSD |
Original Article
[edit]Glendale High School is located in Springfield Missouri. The mascot is a falcon.
Nomination Criteria
[edit]A1 No context. Very short articles lacking sufficient context to identify the subject of the article. Example: "He is a funny man with a red car. He makes people laugh." Context is different from content, treated in A3, below.
Deletion Options
[edit]| rationale | Count | Percent |
|---|---|---|
| Agree with rationale to speedy delete. | 3 | 4.7 |
| Disagree with rationale. Subject of article is clear, but deletable by other criteria. | 2 | 3.1 |
| Disagree with rationale. Subject of article is clear, but this is a case where IAR applies. | 3 | 4.7 |
| Disagree with speedy deletion, speedy deleting of school articles is controversial should be sent to AFD/PROD. | 56 | 87.5 |
Survey Comments
[edit]| Common rationale | Count |
|---|---|
- It should be noted that the "don't delete schools 'cuz they're controversial" argument only comes into play for A7, not all CSD.
- Clear context - school is clearly subject of article
- Borderline though, if someone did complain over a speedy deletion, I would just recommend recreation over undeletion.
- Disagree with deletion. Would take no more than 5 minutes for any admin (indeed any user) to make a perfectly acceptable stub - plenty of info on google.
- Does not meet A1 at all; I would redirect to city article.
- Wouldn't send it to prod or AFD; wikify and add a school stub tag
- there is enough context to identify the subject, and there is likely enough information to write a bigger article.
- Disagree with deletion, let alone speedying. Assuming the school exists, this is easily expandable
- probably not notable, but the inclusionists will murder you if you speedy a school
- Short article but established sufficient context.
- While I wouldn't argue much if it was deleted under this criterion, it's not quite under the criteria.
- Remove speedy, schools should go to AfD really (though primary schools can be redirected to school district)
- prod, in this case, unless more is added
- Most likely would redirect to district page
- Take the time to create a proper stub. Just need to wikilink city and provide URL of school or school system web page and you've got a passable stub. If nonexistent then G3/obvious hoax applies, but check for obscure private schools before G3ing.
- Has plenty of context. High Schools are generally deemed notable.
- High schools are generally held to be notable at AfD. Presuming this is a verifiable school, it should probably be kept.
- enough context to locate
Balloonman's analysis
[edit]A1 is clearly incorrect. You can immediately tell what school and what city you are talking about. Schools are generally not subject to speedy deletion because their deletion (particularly at the HS/College level) is controversial. At most a prod, but in all reality, this could possibly be left alone!